Larry
"Uncle Larry"
I get alot from the disagreements. I think it's a good opportunity to have a really great discussion on a subject, when 2 people are on opposite sides of the fence. Forces me to think in a way I wouldn't do normally. Friction is a great motivator. Ever play when you are mad? I have and I feel like I'm killin it because I have stuff right on the surface I can let out.Funny how I'm disagreeing with you here again, Larry, but not to worry - I just think you should give yourself more credit
I think it's really hard not to be some measure of both art and craft, but probably should qualify that with what I think each means. As I see it, the craft is how well you use the tools at your disposal (with both gear selection and playing ability); and the art of it is what you choose to play or not play as a reflection of your aesthetic and artistic sense.
I think you use both in spades, Larry. From taking great care with your gear selections, tunings and timing issues, to making sure you're forever being appropriate and sensitive to the the music and the other players. Quite possible for a high-caliber craftsman to come in and blast-beat the shit outta yer blooz gig! The art component is definitely part of your vibe.
Why is that an either / or again? ha ha
'
I appreciate the kind words Mike. I don't think it's right for me to say I create art. I will concede that I'd like to think I do some things artfully, but to me that's a big difference than being an artist. But I appreciate the kind words. Really feel free to disagree with me all you want. I like a 5 string bass ha ha. That low B (I think it's a B open) is really in the basement.
This one guy at a jam had an 8 string bass. 8 strings! OK that's insane! A guitar only has 6! This guy was so far over the top. Yea not in a good way either. There was nothing I could do but try and hold it together. Good times.
I've always thought it's what other people, specifically other non-drummer musicians... think of a person's playing that really counts. Like I could sit here and call myself an artist all day, which is a bit presumptuous in my mind to say the least, but to me... that has no value or truth to it at all unless someone else thinks I'm an artist, which I silently still wouldn't agree with, but you know what? I'll accept the compliment. If that's what a person feels then who am I to say it's valid or not? It's all subjective anyway. So it's good manners to agree with the person complimenting them. I've seen my bandleader get compliments and he kind of stomps on the persons enthusiasm by contradicting them. Not the best way to handle what could be a pleasant exchange.
I have my ideas and you don't see it that way sometimes and that's great. Keeps it real. Opens my eyes.